On January 9, 2025, the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., was filled with solemnity as people gathered to honor former President Jimmy Carter. At 100 years old, Carter had achieved a legacy unmatched in U.S. history as the longest-living former president.

His memorial, however, became a subject of discussion for reasons beyond his illustrious life of service.

Close friends Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood performed John Lennon’s 1971 anthem Imagine during the service. While their heartfelt intention was clear, the choice of song sparked controversy online.

Many fans criticized the lyrics, particularly lines such as “Imagine there’s no heaven… Above us only sky,” as inappropriate for a Christian funeral in a historic cathedral.

Some attendees and viewers expressed their discontent, with one fan commenting, “At a devout Christian’s funeral, singing this is tone-deaf.” Others questioned how the song aligned with Carter’s faith, deeming it disrespectful. Criticisms ranged from the song’s message to the performance itself, with remarks about its execution.

Despite the backlash, some viewers appreciated the gesture. Admirers defended the performance as a touching tribute, emphasizing the emotional connection between the singers and the late president. Brooks and Yearwood had a long-standing friendship with the Carters, often collaborating on charitable projects, particularly Habitat for Humanity. For them, Imagine was more than a song; it symbolized Carter’s hopes for unity and peace.

Jimmy Carter had often spoken about his fondness for Lennon’s Imagine, reflecting on its global impact. For Carter, the song transcended boundaries, offering a vision of a better world. In interviews, he described it as a “national anthem” in places like Cuba, where Lennon’s legacy resonates deeply. The song’s message, though challenging to some, aligned with Carter’s belief in bridging divides and fostering understanding.

Brooks and Yearwood’s bond with the Carters extended beyond personal friendship. They worked closely with them on numerous Habitat for Humanity projects, helping build homes for families in need. Their admiration for Carter’s service and humility was evident in their frequent public tributes. During Carter’s 100th birthday in 2024, they commended his lifelong dedication to improving lives, calling him an enduring source of inspiration.

When Rosalynn Carter passed away in late 2023, both Brooks and Yearwood attended her memorial, supporting Carter in his grief. Brooks later reflected on Carter’s resilience, noting his ability to inspire even as his health declined. The couple’s connection to the Carters was deeply rooted in mutual respect and shared values.

The performance of Imagine may have divided opinions, but it underscored Carter’s impact on those who knew him. For Brooks and Yearwood, it was their way of honoring a man who believed in the possibility of a more unified world. While some may debate the song’s suitability, the tribute highlighted Carter’s legacy of service, love, and hope—a legacy that continues to inspire.