The owners of Return to Nature Funeral Home in Colorado, Jon and Carie Hallford, pleaded guilty to federal wire fraud charges on Thursday. They were accused of defrauding clients and misusing nearly $900,000 in pandemic relief funds. The Hallfords allegedly stored 190 decaying bodies in their facility and sent grieving families fake ashes. As part of a plea agreement, they each pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, with prosecutors agreeing not to seek more than 15 years in prison. Additional charges, including corpse abuse and forgery, are pending in Colorado state court. The plea also acknowledges their involvement in COVID-19 fraud and customer deception, which will influence their sentencing.
Jon and Carie Hallford, the owners of Return to Nature Funeral Home in Colorado, misused pandemic relief funds and customer payments for personal expenses, including purchasing luxury vehicles (a GMC Yukon and an Infiniti worth over $120,000), laser body sculpting treatments, and trips to California, Florida, and Las Vegas. They also spent $31,000 on cryptocurrency and bought high-end items from stores like Gucci and Tiffany & Co., according to court documents.
In 2023, authorities discovered 190 decaying bodies in a bug-infested building owned by the funeral home in Penrose, Colorado. The bodies had reportedly been stored as far back as 2019, sometimes stacked on top of one another. In at least two instances, the Hallfords allegedly buried the wrong body. Some families, like Elisabeth Ostly, thought they had received their loved ones’ ashes, only to learn later that the ashes were fake. In Ostly’s case, the ashes she believed to be her father’s turned out to be dry concrete. She expressed the emotional toll this revelation took on her, saying it reset her grieving process and forced her to confront new trauma in therapy.
An investigation revealed that the Hallfords had fabricated cremation records and sent fake ashes to grieving families, further compounding the deceit. The discovery of these remains and the Hallfords’ fraudulent actions prompted outrage and disbelief among the victims. One of the most harrowing testimonies came from Crystina Page, whose son’s body was found in the pile of remains. She described how his body had deteriorated after being left in the building, losing 60% of its weight and being gnawed on by rats and maggots.
This scandal led to changes in Colorado’s funeral home regulations in 2024, including mandatory inspections of funeral homes and the licensing of funeral home personnel. While the Hallfords pleaded guilty to federal fraud charges, many victims, like Page, felt the plea deal didn’t fully address the depth of the harm caused. Page described the conditions of her son’s body in the facility and expressed her frustration, calling the plea deal a mere “scratch on the surface” of the atrocities committed.
